If hitler asked you to electrocute a stranger

If Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger, Would You? Probably

The value of this technique is that the experimenter, as though he were God, can change a prop here, vary a line there, and see how the subject responds.

This electrode is connected to the shock generator in the next room. When Stanley Milgram first wrote this script, he took it to 14 Yale psychology majors and asked them what they thought would happen.

If he gets it right, nothing happens and you go on to the next one. Can't you check in and see if he's all right, please? You mean keep giving him what?

He's in there hollering! Most psychology majors asked about possible results thought that some would break it off early, most in the middle, and few towards the end, voltage wise. By that point, he has resolved the conflict. But that doesn't relieve them of the moral responsibility.

It is about learning, says Jack Williams in a quiet, knowledgeable way. I mean, he told me he can't stand the shock, sir. Wallace comes out in coat and tie. If he could show that Germans are more obedient than Americans, he could then vary the conditions of the experiment and try to find out just what it is that makes some people more obedient than others.

Teacher indicating the unused question: Don't you think you should look in on him, please. What if he's dead in there? I don't get no answer. All he says is that ordinarily we operate in a state of autonomy, which means we pretty much have and assert control over what we do.

Excerpts from the article by Philip Meyer on Milgram experiments. And 30 percent of them obeyed the experimenter and kept on obeying. Teacher relieved to hear response: If, in this study, an anonymous experimenter can successfully command adults to subdue a year old man and force on him painful electric shocks against his protest, one can only wonder what government, with its vastly greater authority and prestige, can command of its subjects".

A hundred and ninety-five volts.

If Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger, Would You? Probably

I absolutely refuse to answer any more. So he went to New York and roamed around the electronic shops until he found some little black switches at Lafayette Radio for a dollar apiece. So he rewrote the script to include some protests from the learner.

The mild-looking accountant draws one, holds it close to his vest like a poker player, looks at it, and says, "Learner".

Milgram hypothesized that Germans have a readiness to obey authority without question, more so than other people. Wallace his unwanted electric shock. An without a civil society, as Thomas Hobbes pointed out in the seventeenth century, we would live in a condition of war, "of every man against every other man," and life would be "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short.

But the naive subject is free to go at any time.

Hitler and the obedience?

Still, 65 percent of the subjects, to year old American males, everyday, ordinary people, like you and me, obediently kept pushing those levers in the belief that they were shocking the mild-mannered learner, whose name was Mr. So you make an appointment and go to an old Romanesque stone structure on High Street with the imposing name of the Yale Interaction Laboratory.Feb 03,  · In the article, “if Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger, Would you?” Philip Meyer discusses how Stanley Milgram wanted to do an experiment that he created to measure obedience of Americans to Germans but, this plan didn’t work because simply to many people where obeying.

If Hitler Asked You to Electrocute a Stranger, Would You? Probably by Philip Meyer Main Concepts Questions Summary In this reading, Milgram brings in a "teacher" and a "learner" to participate in an experiment. Nov 29,  · Best Answer: Hitler convinced people the perfect person was everything he was not and yet people still followed him.

Why because he was very charismatic and, persuasive and good with words so people obeyed him. So "if Hitler asked you to electrocute a stranger would you?"Status: Resolved. The experimenter, as though he were God, can change a prop here, vary a line there, and see how the subject responds.

T are different. The Germans-are. Nov 06,  · Notes: "If Hitler Asked You To Electrocute A Stranger, Would You? Probably" by Philip Meyer Notes: "If Hitler Asked You To Electrocute A Stra Notes: "The Promise" by C. Wright Mills You May Ask Yourself by Dalton Conley summary chap About Me.

dana kim. Nov 28,  · So "if Hitler asked you to electrocute a stranger would you?" the question is could he persuade you to believe it is the right choice to make answer probably.

say two people are debating over a controversial topic, the person with the better choice of words in their argument is going to persuade the people to believe what they're fmgm2018.com: Resolved.

Download
If hitler asked you to electrocute a stranger
Rated 0/5 based on 19 review